Now that Wakefield may be the mystery father, rather than the Sherrif, and the Sherriff supposedly help Madsion captive (for a game) we are going into week 10 of 13, and I still see nothing that doesn't say the GROOM. Sure the sherriff got caught by the trap set by his ex-deputy, but anyone could have walked into that one. It is THOSE DEAD we need to rule out and, when someone is pointed at and blamed, I tend to dismiss them too, so the Sherriff is out, although the Madison kidnapping seems more like a TRAP than anything, who the Sherriff is trying to trap (if he indeed is) is another story.
I stay with the groom, did he silence his brother purposely, was his brother on the verge of telling what he knew and had to be killed - we'll see. I really don't see anyone else who ISn't at the scene of the crime when everyone finds dead bodies, so he will stay on my list until finally ruled out.
What would stink if they brought in a character that was barely mentioned (if ever) and blamed it on him/her. I still say, it takes a lot of work to setup 10ft deep, 8ft round hole in the ground traps (without leaving any sand piles around) without the use of an equipment yard. That one puzzles me, could the Sherriff be in on it, just for the sake of getting is :Daughter" out of there, surely there has to be a better way - maybe he should have just insistedm although he seems tough and organized on the outside, knowing Wakefield is the real father (obviously from his daughters earliest years) he still loves her, but at what cost?