Thanks Lance.
But don't ask me, I'm never sure what the answer to that one is.
I suppose it's different decisions for different set ups, for different beekeepers in different years for different out comes in different areas.
(There's a different answer for you)
That's what makes it too hard a question to answer I can tell you what I've done in the past or what I'm intending to do this year. Whats worked in the past for me and what hasnt worked.You can tell me your set up, with all the info you like but all I can give to you is my opinion on that info you tell me.
Mentoring many newbees has taught me lots. The most important thing I've realized is its the things that people don't tell me or don't see to tell me are the clues that they are missing.
Any how I digress.
What is winter pack down? Or rather what is its purpose?
Answer:To get the hive through winter.
In northern australia that means put another super on. In Canada they move them indoors. USA similar or they rap them. All are different answers (blah, blah see above).
So start at the end, what do you want/need the hive to look like in spring, or mid winter for almond pollination.
How could you achieve this?
What are your specific challenges? Wind/draft, moisture, food source etc.
How do you meet those challenges? Move hive, ventilation, supplement pollen and nectar, etc etc.
So it's not a definite. Say 1 box high or 1 full box of capped honey on top of your brood box etc. Which are all good things you'll hear. They are only guides for you to use with your knowledge of your bees.
So beenic it will be an easier thing to deal with as time goes by.
I'll let you know the definite answer after this winter because I'm sure I'll get it completely right or maybe the winter after or the one after that ......